Return To Home Page PoliTalk - All Politics Is Vocal Find Your Match At PoliTalk PoliTalk - All Politics Is Vocal PoliTalk - Join The Discussion PoliTalk - All Politics Is Vocal Read The PoliTalk Blogs PoliTalk - All Politics Is Vocal View PoliTalk Videos Register For Your PoliTalk Account PoliTalk - All Politics Is Vocal Log In To Your PoliTalk Account
 

Tips? Suggestions? talk@politalk.com
Them Ruskies Ain't Liberals
Posted by J.P. Freire October 30 at 5:22 PM | Permalink | Comments (0)

Via Andrew Sullivan, Daniel Larson argues with Fred Kagan about Russia and Venezuela's democratic rejection of liberalism:

The authoritarianism in Russia and the populist demagoguery in Venezuela are both products of the very elections Kagan boosts. The fact is that liberalism has a small constituency in both countries (outside of a very few western European, Anglophone and North American countries, this has often been the case), and when put before the electorates of Russia and Venezuela liberalism fares very poorly. Some of this has to do with the fact that relatively liberal politics was associated with the wealthy elite and tycoons, and the effects of policies carried out in the name of liberalism were generally poor or even disastrous for the people who now back authoritarian populist leaders. There will be objections that Russian elections in particular are not fully “free and fair,” but against this I would note that even with fully free and fair elections the overwhelming majority would still want nothing to do with the Russian liberals. This is hardly surprising: in mass democracy, the politics of liberty tends to lose and lose badly, while one form of demagoguery or another (be it nationalist or revolutionary socialist) usually prevails.


I hate to break it to you, Daniel, but liberalism is having trouble in Russia because the tools to educate the populace are tightly held by the government. I'm sure that liberalism would be a big treat for the Russian populace if they didn't have to worry about being beaten while practicing free speech, losing sympathizers to assassination or finding their leaders stymied when running for public office.

Under those circumstances, a people with a recent memory of a Soviet Republic would likely know the drill. Mutter under your breath, but don't get dead. Right, Anastasia?


COMMENTS  
 
   
Name Email
   
URL  
 
   
Do you want us to remember your personal information for next time?
Yes
No  
   
Add Your Comments